Debunking Viral Claim About the Talmud and Minors


5 min read
4 min read
3 min read
5 min read
Science and Jewish wisdom agree: happiness grows from relationships, meaning, kindness, presence, and gratitude—practices that rewire your life from within.
We’re looking for happiness in all the wrong places. Research shows that the things you spend years chasing thinking they’ll make you happy barely move the needle.
Here’s what actually makes you flourish — according to science and Jewish wisdom.
You were born with a certain emotional rhythm. Some people spring out of bed humming. Others wake up every morning negotiating with themselves. Scientists call this your “set point,” and yes, it’s partly genetic.
But it’s not fixed.
According to Jewish thought, your nature is only your starting point. “Everything is in the hands of Heaven except for awe of Heaven” (Talmud, Berachot 33b) — meaning your inner life is yours to shape. Teshuva, repentance, self-reflection, and intentional choices all reshape your character. Neuroscience also shows how habits, environment, and attention can literally rewire emotional patterns.
Your income, job title, house, appearance — these externals barely predict long-term happiness.
Research on hedonic adaptation shows that people adjust quickly to improvements and the emotional boost fades fast — even after major gains such as raises, new possessions, or relocations (Brickman & Campbell, 1971; Diener et al., 2006).
Jewish texts redirect you away from externals and toward the internal. “Who is rich? One who is happy with what they have” (Ethics of the Fathers, 4:1). Happiness lives in how you experience your life, not in how impressive it looks from the outside.
You know the pattern: I’ll be happy when work gets easier, when I lose weight, when I move, when I meet someone.
Daniel Gilbert and Timothy Wilson call this miswanting— our habit of mispredicting what will make us happy. ("Miswanting: Some problems in the forecasting of future affective states," published in the book Thinking and Feeling: The Role of Affect in Social Cognition, edited by J.P. Forgas.)
Judaism grounds you in the present moment. Blessings over simple things, transitions marked with intention, Shabbat slowing you down — these practices pull your attention away from the future fantasy and into the life you’re living now. You stop chasing joy and start noticing it.
Negativity bias kept your ancestors alive, but it doesn’t make modern life peaceful. Your mind scans for threats, remembers what went wrong, and imagines what might fall apart next.
Jewish life offers a counterweight: Daily structure, small pauses, community rhythms, rituals that interrupt your spirals, and spiritual practices that soften the inner noise.
These work because they shift the nervous system from threat mode (sympathetic) into calm-and-connection mode (parasympathetic). In other words: they train your brain away from survival reactivity and toward steadiness.
In 2023, the directors of the Harvard Study of Adult Development, the longest-running study of human well-being, summarized 85 years of data in one sentence:
“Good relationships keep us healthier and happier. Full stop.”
Not money.
Not status.
Not comfort.
Genuine, reliable, emotionally safe connection is the strongest predictor of a long, healthy, meaningful life.
The Torah calls human beings “not good” when alone (Genesis 2:18). Marriage, family, Shabbat meals, communal prayer, celebrations and mourning — they all ensure you remain woven into something larger than yourself.
Pleasure is enjoyable, but it flickers. Meaning roots you.
Psychologists describe meaning as a “central stabilizer of well-being,” linked with resilience, coherence, and long-term satisfaction (Steger, 2012).
Judaism is built on meaning. You’re here to elevate the world, repair what’s broken, and live with purpose. Your days have spiritual weight. You are part of a larger story.
Pleasure fades; purpose fortifies.
Acts of kindness release dopamine and oxytocin, chemicals that create connection and joy. You feel lighter, more human, more alive.
Kindness is woven through Jewish law and daily living, with an emphasis on giving tzedakah, hospitality, and communal responsibility. As the Medrash puts it, “More than the wealthy person does for the poor person, the poor person does for the wealthy” (Vayikra Rabbah 34:8). Giving expands you.
Mindfulness studies find that anxiety lives in the future, rumination lives in the past, and well-being rises when attention returns to the present (Keng, Smoski & Robins, Clinical Psychology Review, 2011).
Judaism pulls you back to presence again and again — blessings before and after eating, lighting candles, moments of stillness on Shabbat, rituals that slow your pace. They’re not meant to remove you from life; they place you fully inside it.
Gratitude strengthens resilience, shifts mood, and rewires your attention toward what’s working.
Judaism does not leave gratitude to chance. You wake up reciting Modeh Ani, giving thanks to God for returning your soul. You say blessings throughout the day. You mark new experiences with Shehechiyanu. Gratitude is a constant practice that becomes a lens through which you view the world.
Prioritize real face time. A single meaningful conversation can lift your mood for hours.
Step away from your screens on purpose. A short digital timeout resets your nervous system.
Train your mind toward gratitude. List three things each morning; watch your perspective shift.
Do one small act of kindness. Tiny moments of generosity light up the neural circuits of joy.
Find a moment of flow. Choose one task that absorbs you. Let time fall away.

Just noting that unhappiness/ sadness is not the same as depression. Depression is a disease that can be treated with therapy and possibly medication. If someone feels miserable all the time, they should get professional help.
TIME backwards is EMIT
It takes TIME to EMIT anything, and it takes TIME for EMES, truth.
Patience is required. Perhaps, if we close our eyes more often, we will gain more patience. (A blind person has to have patience, to avoid accidents, etc)
CLOSE your eyes more often and feel the difference in your FOCUS... Thanks much
Dear Devora,
A new idea popped into my head to help with PHONE addiction, you mentioned,
I am an IDEA PERSON, but all too often my ideas get rejected, because people do not appreciate them, or they think the ideas are obvious to anyone.
Here is an idea for Aish.com:
Why doesn't Aish have FOOTNOTE warnings on excessive PHONE / Screen use?
Such warnings could appear on each and every Aish.com entry,
In addition, short suggestions, like EYE CLOSING pauses, could be be given.
Much thanks, again, for this wonderful advice.
"Your circumstances matter far less than you assume" Well, I think if most folks had to choose they'd rather be unhappy rich than happy poor. Money can make all the difference. During the recent government shutdown my husband's job was considered essential but he wasn't receiving any salary. Fortunately we could tap into our rainy-day fund to weather the storm--very fortunate as we got hit with 3 unexpected expenses. Many people weren't so lucky with no salary, SNAP, or other resources to get by. Circumstances do matter.
So well written and well said!
so well said!
So true! I agree a hundred per cent!